Practical guide

Public transport accident in France: compensation and key steps

A public transport accident may result from sudden braking, a collision, closing doors, a fall while boarding or alighting, crowd movement or a defect in a station. The compensation rules depend first…

Free initial consultation — no obligation.

A public transport accident may result from sudden braking, a collision, closing doors, a fall while boarding or alighting, crowd movement or a defect in a station.

The compensation rules depend first on the mode of transport. A passenger injured on a bus is not necessarily subject to the same rules as someone injured on a train, an RER service, the metro or a tram running on a dedicated track.

The exact location also matters: the vehicle, platform, corridor, stairs, stop, station entrance, interchange area or a separate commercial space.

This guide explains the first steps to take, the evidence to preserve, the main legal frameworks that may apply and the points to check before accepting a position or an offer.

Which situations does this guide cover?

This page mainly covers personal injury accidents connected with the functioning or operation of public transport.

  • sudden braking or an evasive manoeuvre on a bus, coach or shuttle;
  • a fall inside a vehicle that is moving or temporarily stopped;
  • a collision involving a bus or another vehicle;
  • an injury while boarding or alighting;
  • doors closing on a passenger, an item of clothing or an object;
  • an accident inside a metro, RER or train carriage;
  • a fall into the gap between the platform and the train;
  • an accident involving a tram;
  • crowd movement, luggage or another passenger causing a fall;
  • an accident in a station involving an aspect of its operation or infrastructure.

If the accident results from the operation of a lift or escalator, see the guide Lift or escalator accidents (in French). Intentional violence is mainly covered in the guide Assault victims: steps to take and compensation (in French).

An accident in a station car park is more appropriately covered by the guide Car park accidents (in French). If the transport was included in a package holiday, the page Accidents during an organised holiday (in French) may also be useful.

Which mode of transport was involved in the accident?

Not all public transport is governed by the same legal framework. Start by identifying the vehicle, the network and the location of the accident precisely.

Bus, coach or road shuttle

A bus, coach or road shuttle is a motor vehicle. When it is involved in a road traffic accident, the French Act of 5 July 1985 may apply, including where the injured person was travelling under a contract of carriage.

A collision with another vehicle is not always necessary: a fall inside a bus may fall within this framework if the vehicle was involved in the accident.

Tram

For a tram, the layout at the exact location of the accident must be checked. The Act of 5 July 1985 excludes trams running on tracks reserved for their exclusive use.

The fact that the track is generally reserved for trams does not settle the issue. The precise point of impact or fall must be examined: kerbs, barriers, pedestrian crossings, pavements, surfacing, access for other users and the actual separation of the track.

Train or RER rail service

For rail services within its scope, the European regulation on rail passengers’ rights and the annexed CIV rules may govern the carrier’s liability.

These rules cover, in particular, accidents connected with railway operations that occur while the passenger is in, entering or leaving a railway vehicle. However, the French Transport Code provides for different applications and exemptions for national, regional, urban and suburban services.

Metro

The metro should not automatically be treated in the same way as a bus or a mainline train. Distinctions must be made between an accident inside a carriage, boarding or alighting, the gap between the platform and the vehicle, the operation of the doors and an accident solely involving the platform or fixed equipment.

The applicable legal basis will therefore depend on the role of the train, the operator, the infrastructure and, potentially, another user.

Station, platform or corridor

A fall on a platform, in a corridor or in an interchange area does not automatically fall under the same legal framework as an accident on board.

It is necessary to determine whether the injury arose from the transport itself, boarding or alighting, a slippery floor, a hole, inadequate lighting, crowd movement, a shop, mechanical equipment or another operator.

The mode of transport and exact location determine the next steps

Buses, trams, trains, RER services and the metro are not necessarily governed by the same rules. A fall inside a carriage, an accident involving a door and a fall on a platform must be analysed separately.

Which rules apply to a passenger injured on a bus?

The Act of 5 July 1985 applies to victims of a road traffic accident involving a motor vehicle, even when they are travelling under a contract of carriage.

A passenger is an injured person who was not the driver

For personal injury, a passenger benefits from the protective rules for injured persons who were not driving, subject to the exceptions set out in Article 3 of the Act of 5 July 1985.

This must be distinguished from the position of an injured driver, whose own fault may limit or exclude compensation for their personal injury.

For more detail, see the guides Passengers injured in an accident (in French) and Injured pedestrians, cyclists and passengers (in French).

A collision is not always necessary

A fall inside a bus can constitute a road traffic accident without a collision with another vehicle. The injured person must nevertheless establish that they were present, the circumstances of the fall, their injuries and the connection between those injuries and the accident.

A stationary bus can still be involved

The Cour de cassation has held that a bus remains in circulation even during a prolonged stop on the route it serves. A passenger’s fall inside it may therefore constitute an accident involving the vehicle.

Another passenger’s actions do not automatically disapply these rules

Someone knocked off balance by another passenger while getting off a stationary bus may still fall within the Act of 5 July 1985. A third party’s actions should therefore not automatically lead to the carrier or motor insurer being ruled out.

How can sudden braking be proved?

Sudden braking is often disputed because it does not always leave physical traces. An accurate account and prompt reporting are therefore essential.

  • the exact date and time;
  • the route, direction and stop concerned;
  • the previous and next stations;
  • the bus fleet number or visible registration number;
  • the seat occupied or the place where the person was standing;
  • any handrail or grab pole being used;
  • other passengers who were thrown off balance;
  • any object, pushchair or luggage displaced by the braking;
  • whether the driver stopped and staff intervened;
  • any call to the emergency services or immediate report.

A factual description is preferable to a general conclusion about speed. It is more useful to explain where the injured person was, what they were holding, the movement they felt, how other passengers reacted and what happened immediately afterwards.

What should you do if the accident happens while boarding or alighting?

Document the precise stage at which the accident occurred, as the doors, step, gap beside the platform or the vehicle moving off may have played a part.

  • the name of the stop or station;
  • the side on which the doors opened;
  • the height of the pavement or platform;
  • the gap between the vehicle and the platform;
  • any step or threshold to cross;
  • whether the bus was lowered or a ramp deployed;
  • any warning sound and how long the doors remained open;
  • whether the doors closed on a body part, clothing or an object;
  • whether the vehicle moved off before the passenger had finished getting out;
  • the response of the driver, train manager or staff member.

Under the applicable rail framework, accidents occurring while a passenger enters or leaves the vehicle may fall within the CIV rules when they are connected with railway operations.

Does the Badinter Act apply to a tram accident?

The answer depends on the layout at the precise location. Article 1 of the Act of 5 July 1985 excludes trams running on tracks reserved for their exclusive use.

Where the track is reserved for the tram’s exclusive use

The 1985 Act may not apply where the relevant section is exclusively reserved for trams and clearly separated from other traffic. The Cour de cassation reached that conclusion for a track separated from road vehicles and laid out so that the point of impact was reserved for the tram.

Where the track is not separated

By contrast, the 1985 Act was held to apply where, at the precise point of impact, the track was not separated from the pavement alongside it.

Useful evidence

  • photographs of the point of impact;
  • pedestrian crossings and traffic lights;
  • kerbs, bollards and barriers;
  • any dividing strip or absence of separation;
  • the track surfacing;
  • signs and road markings;
  • the injured person’s path;
  • the tram’s path and direction of travel.

It is therefore not enough to describe the whole line as running on a dedicated track. The layout at the precise location of the accident is decisive.

Which rules may apply to a train or RER accident?

European Regulation 2021/782 applies to rail journeys and services within its scope. The French Transport Code specifies the provisions applicable to urban, suburban, regional and other rail services.

An accident connected with railway operations

The CIV rules provide for the carrier’s liability for injuries caused by an accident connected with railway operations that occurs while the passenger is in, entering or leaving the vehicle.

This may include movement of the train, closing doors or a defect affecting boarding or alighting, subject to the conditions and grounds for exemption set out in those rules.

Fault on the passenger’s part

The rail carrier may be relieved of liability to the extent that the accident was due to the passenger’s fault. The Cour de cassation confirmed this in a case involving a passenger injured by an automatic door closing.

It is therefore important to describe the warnings, how the door operated, the injured person’s position, how crowded it was and any staff intervention precisely.

Was the accident connected with the vehicle or the infrastructure?

Inside the carriage, while boarding or while alighting

Examine the vehicle’s operation, the doors, braking, the gap beside the platform, announcements, the staff present and any movement at the time of the accident.

On the platform or while changing services

Examine the condition of the platform or corridor, the floor, lighting, obstacles, signs, crowds, the proximity of a train, barriers and the identity of the infrastructure manager.

On an escalator or in a lift

If the mechanical operation of the equipment is involved, see the page Lift or escalator accidents (in French). Maintenance and technical inspections are addressed separately there.

What should you do immediately after the accident?

Get medical care for the injured person

Health is the priority. Call the emergency services when necessary and keep the initial medical certificate, the emergency response report, emergency department records, examination results, prescriptions and sick leave certificates.

Notify staff immediately

Depending on the location, notify the driver, station staff, ticket inspector, train manager, platform staff, security service or station reception. Ask for the accident to be recorded.

Identify the journey precisely

  • date and time;
  • route and direction;
  • stop or station;
  • vehicle or train number;
  • train unit, coach or carriage;
  • door used;
  • seat occupied or approximate location;
  • previous and next stations.

Confirm the facts in writing

A telephone call is not always enough to preserve evidence. Promptly send an email or complaint form setting out the circumstances, the transport involved, the injuries, witnesses and a request to preserve relevant evidence.

What should the incident report contain?

The incident report or declaration should make it possible to identify the journey and the event that caused the injury without ambiguity.

  • date and time;
  • route and direction;
  • bus, train unit or train number;
  • stop, platform or station;
  • door, carriage or location concerned;
  • braking, collision, movement or doors closing;
  • witnesses;
  • injuries reported;
  • emergency services called;
  • staff present;
  • any third party involved;
  • initial measures taken.

If no copy is provided, the injured person should send their own account as soon as their condition allows. The report is useful evidence that the incident was reported, but it is not necessarily an admission of liability.

Why keep your ticket, travel pass or validation record?

The travel document helps establish that you were a passenger and identify the journey.

  • paper ticket;
  • Navigo or other travel pass validation record;
  • screenshot from the app;
  • season ticket;
  • bank payment;
  • reservation or train ticket;
  • passenger account history;
  • purchase receipt.

These documents can confirm the time, network, train or route. They do not, on their own, prove sudden braking, abnormal door closure, the cause of the fall or the injuries.

The absence of a ticket does not automatically settle the legal issue, but it can make identifying the journey and proving that the person was there much more difficult.

What evidence should be preserved?

Photographs

  • route sign or station name;
  • platform, stop or boarding area;
  • door and step;
  • gap between the platform and the train;
  • floor, obstacle or lighting;
  • seat, grab pole or location occupied;
  • bus, train unit or carriage number;
  • any temporary closure or signs put up after the accident.

Witnesses

Keep the names, telephone numbers, email addresses and locations of people who saw the accident or its immediate aftermath. Ask for a factual description of the movement, noise, any other passengers falling and the staff’s initial statements.

Operational records

Request the preservation of the driver’s or staff member’s report, the incident log, journey data, door-opening times, calls to the control centre and records of security staff intervention. This does not mean that those records will be disclosed immediately.

Medical evidence

A short interval between the accident, the onset of pain and the first medical consultation helps establish the chronology. Continue documenting how the condition develops, without making your own diagnosis.

Protect personal data

Do not post your medical records, your full travel pass number, videos unnecessarily showing other passengers or a witness’s contact details in a comment or on social media.

Keep the original files and ask for an appropriate channel before sending sensitive documents.

How can you request CCTV footage?

Send the request promptly to the person responsible for the CCTV system or to the network operator.

  • date and a short time window;
  • route and direction;
  • station, platform or stop;
  • vehicle, train unit or train number;
  • carriage or door concerned;
  • a description that allows the injured person to be identified;
  • a request to preserve the relevant footage;
  • a request for access to footage showing the injured person.

The CNIL, the French data protection authority, states that people who are filmed have a right of access to footage showing them. The rights of others must nevertheless be protected, for example by masking their images or limiting disclosure.

The retention period must be proportionate and, for the CCTV systems concerned, cannot exceed one month. A few days are often enough for routine checks: a late request may therefore arrive after the footage has been erased.

Who may be liable for the accident?

Who to contact depends on the mode of transport, the location and the event that caused the injury.

  • the driver or the person legally responsible for the control of a bus;
  • the road transport carrier;
  • the railway undertaking;
  • the metro or tram operator;
  • the station manager;
  • the infrastructure manager;
  • a maintenance or cleaning company;
  • the person legally responsible for the control of equipment;
  • the driver of another vehicle;
  • another user;
  • the perpetrator of an assault.

The insurer must be considered separately. It may cover one of these parties’ liability, but it is not the party that physically caused the braking, the door closure or the platform defect.

What should you do if another passenger caused the fall?

Distinguish between accidental jostling, luggage left in a passageway, a falling object, a pushchair, a bicycle, crowd movement and a deliberate push.

  • identify the passenger where possible;
  • collect witness accounts;
  • photograph the object concerned;
  • ask staff to intervene;
  • report any role played by the vehicle or the crowd;
  • obtain the third party’s insurer’s contact details where the circumstances allow.

On a bus subject to the Act of 5 July 1985, another passenger’s actions do not automatically remove the rights of an injured person who was not driving. In cases of intentional violence, see the guide for assault victims (in French).

Which insurance policies may apply?

Bus or other road vehicle

  • the bus’s third-party liability insurance;
  • the other vehicle’s insurance;
  • driver injury cover if the driver is the injured person;
  • the Guarantee Fund in certain cases involving an uninsured or unidentified vehicle.

Train, RER, metro or tram

  • the operator’s liability insurance or cover;
  • the infrastructure manager’s insurance;
  • a maintenance or cleaning contractor’s insurance;
  • another user’s personal liability cover.

Personal cover

  • everyday accident cover (garantie accidents de la vie);
  • legal expenses insurance;
  • personal accident insurance;
  • cover attached to a card, licence or activity;
  • school or extracurricular accident insurance for a child, depending on the policy.

Reporting a claim does not establish that it is covered. Thresholds, limits, excesses, exclusions and time limits must be checked in each policy, and any refusal should be requested in writing.

Which medical and financial documents should you keep?

Medical documents

  • initial medical certificate (in French);
  • emergency response and emergency department reports;
  • hospital records and imaging;
  • prescriptions and specialist reports;
  • rehabilitation and nursing care records;
  • sick leave certificates;
  • records of psychological care where medically initiated;
  • medical assessment report;
  • certificate of medical stabilisation (consolidation) or deterioration.

Employment and financial documents

  • payslips and employer statements;
  • evidence of absence from work and lost income;
  • medical and travel expenses;
  • personal assistance;
  • damaged equipment or clothing;
  • damaged glasses, a telephone or other personal belongings.

Transport documents

  • travel document or validation record;
  • incident report;
  • photographs and videos;
  • witness accounts;
  • complaint and the operator’s response;
  • any criminal complaint;
  • insurers’ responses.

The guide Obtaining your medical records (in French) may help you obtain missing documents.

When might a medico-legal assessment be needed?

An assessment may be considered where the injuries are significant, treatment is prolonged, surgery was necessary, pain persists, sick leave is lengthy or lasting effects are possible.

It may examine the initial injuries, their connection with the accident, treatment, pain, temporary loss of independence, medical stabilisation, lasting effects, personal assistance, lost income and future needs.

To prepare for this stage, see Preparing for a medico-legal assessment (in French), The role of the medical adviser (in French) and Should you consult a lawyer before the assessment? (in French)

What consequences may be compensated?

Losses are assessed only after the applicable legal framework, entitlement to compensation or relevant liability has been established. Each consequence must then be supported by evidence and linked to the accident.

Economic losses

  • healthcare costs and out-of-pocket expenses;
  • travel costs;
  • lost income;
  • personal assistance;
  • equipment and personal belongings;
  • future care and expenses;
  • wider impact on working life.

Non-economic losses

  • temporary functional impairment;
  • pain and suffering;
  • disfigurement;
  • permanent functional impairment;
  • loss of enjoyment of leisure activities;
  • medically documented psychological consequences.

Losses suffered by close relatives

  • assistance provided;
  • expenses incurred;
  • lost income;
  • the personal impact on them.

An overview of the different heads of loss is provided in the guide Compensable losses after an accident (in French).

Specific time limits when a bus is involved

Where the road traffic accident framework applies, the motor insurer must comply with the specific time limits in the French Insurance Code for making an offer or providing a reasoned response.

In particular, an offer for personal injury must be made within eight months of the accident. If the condition has not stabilised, the offer may be provisional, and the final offer must be made within five months of the insurer being informed of medical stabilisation.

These time limits must not automatically be applied to metro or train accidents, or to falls not involving a motor vehicle.

Which specific time limits should you watch for after a railway accident?

Where the CIV rules annexed to the European regulation apply, specific time limits must be checked.

  • in principle, the accident must be reported to the carrier within twelve months of becoming aware of the injury, subject to the stated exceptions;
  • if the report is made verbally, the carrier must provide written acknowledgement of it;
  • in principle, the passenger’s personal injury action is subject to a three-year limitation period running from the day after the accident;
  • for certain other persons entitled to claim, the period is three years from the day after the death, but cannot extend beyond five years after the accident.

These time limits concern the applicable rail framework. They do not automatically replace all other civil, contractual or insurance time limits that may be relevant.

What other time limit may apply?

For a liability action concerning personal injury that is not subject to a specific time limit, Article 2226 of the French Civil Code generally provides for a ten-year period from medical stabilisation of the original or aggravated injury.

This period should never be a reason to wait: footage may be erased, journey data deleted, the driver or staff member may become difficult to identify, witnesses may disperse and memories may become less precise.

Insurance policies may also impose shorter time limits for reporting the accident, seeking cover or challenging a refusal.

What should you do if the carrier or its insurer refuses compensation?

Ask for a written response setting out the precise reason for the refusal.

  • is it disputed that the accident took place?
  • is the injured person’s presence or journey disputed?
  • has the vehicle or train unit not been sufficiently identified?
  • is the braking or door closure denied?
  • is the bus’s involvement disputed?
  • is it argued that the tram was running on a track reserved for its exclusive use?
  • is the connection with railway operations disputed?
  • is fault on the passenger’s part or another user’s actions being relied on?
  • is the connection between the accident and the injuries disputed?
  • are some losses considered insufficiently supported by evidence?

Then compare that reasoning with the travel document, incident report, witness accounts, photographs, footage, journey data, medical records and the legal framework specific to the mode of transport.

A general objection is rarely enough. It should address the reason given point by point.

Which mistakes can weaken the case?

  • leaving the vehicle or station without reporting the accident;
  • failing to record the route, direction or time;
  • failing to note the vehicle, train or train unit number;
  • losing the ticket or validation record;
  • failing to identify witnesses;
  • requesting footage too late;
  • failing to have the injuries medically documented;
  • confusing the rules for buses, the metro, trams and trains;
  • failing to pinpoint the location of a tram accident;
  • presenting the insurer as the party that caused the accident;
  • publishing images or personal data about other passengers;
  • accepting an offer before medical stabilisation;
  • overlooking a specific rail time limit.

Frequently asked questions

Does the Act of 5 July 1985 apply to a fall on a bus?

It may apply where the road traffic accident involves the bus. A collision with another vehicle is not necessary in every situation.

Does the bus have to be moving?

No. The Cour de cassation has accepted that a bus making a prolonged stop on its route could still be involved in a passenger’s fall inside it.

Does a passenger benefit from protective rules?

Yes. Where the Act of 5 July 1985 applies, a passenger is an injured person who was not driving within the meaning of Article 3, subject to the exceptions in that provision.

Is a ticket essential?

It is very useful for proving the journey and identifying the vehicle. Its absence does not automatically prevent any claim, but it often makes proof more difficult.

Does the Badinter Act always apply to trams?

No. It does not apply where, at the exact location of the accident, the tram was running on a track reserved for its exclusive use.

Does a train passenger have to prove fault by the carrier?

Under the applicable rail framework, the carrier is liable for injuries caused by an accident connected with railway operations that occurs inside the vehicle or while entering or leaving it, subject to the stated grounds for exemption.

Can a rail passenger’s own fault reduce compensation?

Yes, to the extent that the accident was due to that fault.

Does a fall on a platform always fall under the contract of carriage?

No. The location, stage of the journey, role of the train and any defect on the platform must be examined.

Can you request the footage?

Yes. The injured person can request access to footage showing them and ask for it to be preserved. The rights of other people filmed must be protected.

What should you do if another passenger caused the fall?

Identify that passenger, collect witness accounts and examine the role of the vehicle or the organisation of the transport service. On a bus subject to the 1985 Act, a third party’s actions do not automatically remove the passenger’s rights.

Useful resources

For further information, you can consult the following official legislation and court decisions:

Bus, metro, tram and train

Have you been injured in a public transport accident?

The firm can examine your ticket or other proof of travel, the route, time, incident report, witness accounts, available footage, initial medical documents and the applicable legal framework, depending on whether a bus, tram, metro, RER or train was involved.

For an initial discussion, there is no need to send your entire medical file or videos unnecessarily identifying other passengers without being asked. An appropriate way to send documents can be agreed after that first discussion.

Similar Posts