Practical guide
Fall in a hotel or restaurant in France: how to claim compensation
A fall in a hotel or restaurant can cause a fracture, a head injury, a back or knee injury, time off work and, in some cases, lasting effects. However, compensation after a…
Free initial consultation — no obligation.
A fall in a hotel or restaurant can cause a fracture, a head injury, a back or knee injury, time off work and, in some cases, lasting effects.
However, compensation after a fall in a hotel or restaurant is not automatic. The precise cause of the accident must be identified: liquid on the floor, a hard-to-see step, an unsecured mat, inadequate lighting, unstable furniture, faulty bathroom fittings or another abnormal condition.
The legal basis also depends on the injured person’s circumstances. A hotel or restaurant customer may have a contractual relationship with the operator, whereas an accompanying person, visitor or other third party may fall under non-contractual liability rules.
This guide explains the initial steps, the evidence to preserve, the parties that may be involved, the insurers to contact and the points to check before accepting a position or an offer.
Which situations does this guide cover?
This page mainly concerns falls in accommodation or dining areas that are open to customers and visitors.
- slipping in a lobby, reception area or restaurant dining room;
- liquid, food or cleaning products on the floor;
- an entrance mat that is raised, displaced or inadequately secured;
- an obstruction or furniture in a walkway;
- a step, threshold or change in level that is difficult to see;
- a fall on stairs or a landing;
- an accident in a guest room;
- a fall in a bathroom or toilet facilities;
- a faulty washbasin, shower, door or other fitting;
- an uneven, wet, cluttered or poorly lit terrace;
- a glass door, window or partition that is difficult to see.
Where the accident mainly involves a car park, swimming pool, lift, escalator or leisure activity provided by the establishment, the liability issues and evidence may differ.
- Accidents in car parks (in French);
- Swimming pool accidents (in French);
- Lift or escalator accidents (in French);
- Accidents during leisure activities (in French);
- Falls in shops (in French), where the accident occurs in a separate retail area.
What should you do immediately after the fall?
Have the injuries treated and their date recorded
The injured person’s health comes first. Depending on the severity, call the emergency services, seek medical attention promptly and keep the initial medical findings.
- initial medical certificate;
- emergency service or emergency department report;
- diagnostic imaging;
- prescriptions and advice on monitoring symptoms;
- sick notes and follow-up certificates;
- relevant photographs of injuries, taken with due regard for privacy.
Report the accident to the establishment
It is useful to notify reception, management, the restaurant manager or the staff present immediately and ask for an incident report to be completed.
Record the timeline
- date and time;
- name and address of the establishment;
- room number, floor, room or precise area;
- what you were doing at the time;
- what caused the fall;
- people present;
- first aid provided and time of the medical consultation.
Confirm the facts in writing
A telephone call leaves little evidence. A factual email sent promptly to the establishment can record the location, time, circumstances, injuries and witnesses, together with a request to preserve relevant documents and footage.
Is the hotel or restaurant automatically liable?
No. The injured person’s presence at the establishment and the fact that a fall occurred are not, on their own, enough to establish the operator’s liability.
A breach, defect or physical element that played a part in the accident must be identified, and the link between the fall and the injuries must then be established.
The evidence may concern the condition of the floor, the position of an obstacle, the lighting, the layout of a staircase, the way a fitting was secured, the absence of warning signs or cleaning work.
A safety obligation, not a guarantee against every fall
Services must provide the level of safety that a person can legitimately expect under normal or reasonably foreseeable conditions.
This principle does not remove the need for the injured person to establish the circumstances, the harm and the causal link. The establishment’s liability does not follow merely from where the accident happened.
Was the injured person a customer of the establishment?
Hotel guest
The accommodation contract may give rise to an examination of the operator’s contractual liability. Keep the booking confirmation, invoice, room number, terms and conditions, correspondence and the identity of the person who made the booking.
Restaurant customer
The contractual relationship may also require an examination of the restaurant operator’s duties of care, maintenance and supervision. Evidence of the service, bill or payment may be useful without, on its own, establishing the cause of the fall.
Accompanying person, visitor, delivery worker or other third party
Depending on the circumstances, a person who does not personally benefit from the contract may have a claim based on non-contractual liability. It is then necessary to identify fault, negligence, carelessness or the role of an object under another party’s custody and control.
The legal classification does not depend solely on the name on the booking. The service actually provided, the person’s status and each party’s role must be examined.
What safety obligation does a hotel operator have?
A hotel operator must take appropriate precautions for receiving guests and allowing them to move around the premises, but its contractual safety obligation is not an absolute guarantee against every fall.
The Cour de cassation upheld a finding that a hotel operator was not liable where the staircase presented no particular danger, had a handrail and the glass door was not positioned too close to the final steps.
The assessment must therefore focus on the actual layout, maintenance, lighting, warnings, any earlier reports and the link between the alleged defect and the fall.
In what circumstances may a restaurant’s liability be considered?
The issues may include inadequate cleaning, maintenance, warning signs, layout or the securing of a fitting.
- liquid or food on the floor that was not dealt with within an appropriate time;
- a recently washed area without sufficiently visible warning signs;
- an unstable mat;
- a table, chair, display stand or trolley placed in an aisle;
- a step or change in level that is difficult to see;
- inadequate lighting;
- a damaged or cluttered terrace;
- a toilet fixture, washbasin, door or other fitting that is inadequately secured or maintained.
In a case decided by the Cour de cassation, a customer’s injuries had been caused or aggravated by an inadequately secured washbasin in a restaurant’s toilets. Any fault on the customer’s part could not be presumed without being established.
What role did the floor, step, mat or furniture play?
Where the object was moving
The causal role may be easier to identify where an object falls, tips over, moves, breaks, closes or strikes the injured person.
- an unstable chair or table;
- a door closing suddenly;
- a piece of furniture, sign or parasol tipping over;
- a washbasin or bathroom fitting coming loose;
- a mat slipping underfoot.
Where the object was stationary or inert
Where a floor, step, threshold, mat, fixed item of furniture or partition is involved, it is generally necessary to establish an abnormal condition that made that element the cause of the harm.
- liquid or a foreign substance making the floor abnormally slippery;
- a folded or raised mat;
- a step that is difficult to see;
- a raised edge or threshold that is not visible;
- an obstacle placed in a walkway;
- lighting that conceals a change in level;
- a glass partition that is not sufficiently visible.
Simply stating that the floor was wet or that the step was not seen may be insufficient if the abnormal condition and its causal role are not documented.
Where did the fall happen?
Lobby, reception area or restaurant dining room
- liquid, food or cleaning products;
- mats and floor coverings;
- luggage, trolleys or furniture;
- table and chair legs;
- lighting and signs;
- the movement of staff and customers.
Corridor
- a housekeeping or service trolley;
- a cable, threshold, raised edge or change in floor covering;
- a door opening into the walkway;
- the width of the walkway;
- lighting and visibility.
Stairs or landing
Photograph the overall view, the first and last steps, the floor covering, stair nosings, contrast, handrail, lighting, landing, nearby doors and any signs of moisture.
Guest room
- space to walk around the bed;
- carpet, rugs or floor coverings;
- furniture, cables or luggage equipment;
- a step, raised edge or threshold;
- night-time lighting;
- a door, window or large glass panel.
Bathroom or toilets
- water on the floor and the condition of the floor covering;
- the bath, shower, raised edges and mats;
- grab rails;
- the washbasin, toilet bowl, door and fixings;
- ventilation and lighting;
- any previous report of a defect.
Terrace
- a paving slab, decking board, joint or difference in level;
- rain, frost, moisture or recent cleaning;
- furniture, a parasol, cable or planter;
- lighting;
- the transition between indoor and outdoor areas.
Can accessibility rules be useful?
Yes, particularly where the fall is linked to an access route, staircase, step, threshold, handrail, lack of contrast, glass partition, lighting or toilet facilities.
However, the applicable rules depend on the building, its age and category, the work carried out and any equivalent solutions or exemptions. A technical requirement should therefore not be applied mechanically without checking which rules govern the premises.
The rules for establishments open to the public cover, among other things, horizontal and vertical circulation, floors, doors, toilets, lighting and equipment. For stairs, the applicable framework may include requirements relating to stair nosings, contrast, slip resistance, handrails and lighting.
Public accessibility register
The operator of an establishment open to the public must prepare a public accessibility register. This register sets out the services offered and the administrative and technical documents relating to accessibility.
It is not an accident report and does not necessarily contain cleaning schedules or all maintenance checks. It may nevertheless help identify the accessibility arrangements declared and the documents available.
What evidence should you keep after the fall?
Photograph the scene before it changes
- the facade, entrance and name of the establishment;
- an overall view of the lobby, dining room, corridor, guest room or terrace;
- the exact place where the fall occurred;
- the liquid, mat, step, threshold, furniture or fitting involved;
- the position of the element in relation to the walkway;
- the presence or absence of a warning sign;
- the actual lighting conditions;
- any repair, cleaning or repositioning after the accident.
Keep evidence of your status as a customer or visitor
- the booking and electronic confirmation;
- the invoice or restaurant bill;
- proof of payment;
- the room number or access card;
- the contract, accommodation voucher or event invitation;
- correspondence with the establishment.
These documents establish your presence and may help determine your relationship with the operator. They do not necessarily prove the cause of the fall.
Identify witnesses
It is useful to ask for the names, telephone numbers and email addresses of people who saw the fall or observed the condition of the premises immediately afterwards. Their accounts should remain factual.
Keep the original files
Photographs and videos should be kept in their original format, with their dates and metadata where possible. A working copy can be made without deleting the original.
Protect personal data
Avoid publishing sensitive photographs of injuries, a complete medical file, a room number or images that unnecessarily identify other customers or staff in a comment or sending them through an unverified channel.
For an initial discussion, a short timeline, the booking or invoice, a few photographs of the scene and the main medical documents are generally sufficient.
What should the incident report contain?
The report or statement prepared by the establishment should record the circumstances without requiring the injured person to sign an account they dispute.
- date and time;
- the exact location, floor, room or guest room number;
- what was happening at the time;
- the observed or alleged cause;
- people present and witnesses;
- first aid and any call to the emergency services;
- any photographs taken by the establishment;
- measures taken after the accident;
- work carried out by a cleaning or maintenance company.
The statement provides useful evidence that the accident was reported. It does not necessarily amount to an admission of liability.
If no copy is provided, the injured person can send their own email summarising the events and ask for it to be kept with the establishment’s internal records of the incident.
Which cleaning or maintenance records should be preserved?
Depending on the alleged cause, a written request may seek the preservation of the following documents:
- cleaning schedules and attendance logs;
- the identity of the service provider involved;
- an internal report of the defect;
- a repair or replacement order;
- work on the lighting;
- replacement of a mat;
- maintenance of toilet facilities or equipment;
- inspection of the stairs, terrace or a door;
- repairs carried out after the fall;
- an earlier complaint about the same hazard.
Asking for these documents to be preserved does not mean they will all be disclosed voluntarily. Where an important private document continues to be withheld, a court measure or a formal request to the insurer may be needed.
How can you request CCTV footage?
The request should be sent promptly to the person responsible for the system or to the establishment, as footage is kept for a limited period.
- the date of the accident;
- the time or a short time window;
- the precise area, floor, room or corridor;
- a description allowing the person to be identified;
- a request to preserve the relevant footage;
- a request for access to images showing the injured person.
Disclosure may require other people shown in the footage to be obscured or otherwise protected. The injured person should therefore not assume that they will immediately receive an unedited file containing footage from every camera.
Who may be liable for the fall?
The relevant party depends on the precise location, the origin of the defect and who operated, maintained, installed or controlled the element involved.
- the hotel operator;
- the restaurant operator;
- the owner of the premises;
- the management company;
- the landlord or association of co-owners;
- the cleaning company;
- the maintenance contractor;
- the manufacturer or installer of equipment;
- the event organiser;
- the organiser or retailer of a package holiday;
- the person with custody and control of an item of furniture or an object;
- another customer, where their conduct or an object under their custody and control directly caused the harm.
The insurer must not be confused with the liable party. It may provide cover for one of the parties’ liability within the terms of the policy.
Should a claim be brought against the operator or the owner?
The answer depends, in particular, on the part of the building involved, the origin of the defect, who had custody and control of the equipment and how responsibility for repairs and maintenance was allocated.
- liquid or food in the dining room: the operator or cleaning company;
- stairs or a structural defect: the operator, owner or association of co-owners, depending on their responsibilities;
- a faulty washbasin or toilet fitting: the operator, owner, installer or maintenance contractor;
- a shared terrace: the property manager or operator, depending on who controlled and maintained it;
- a private event: the operator’s role may need to be distinguished from the organiser’s.
Claims should therefore not automatically be addressed only to the business name displayed on the premises.
What if the hotel was included in a package holiday?
A trader selling a package holiday is liable as a matter of law for the performance of the services included in the contract, even where other providers deliver them, subject to the grounds for exemption provided by the French Tourism Code.
Keep the travel contract, voucher, invoice, itinerary, the identity of the organiser or retailer, the hotel confirmation, any complaint made during the stay and the responses received.
A booking platform should not automatically be treated as a package organiser. Its role depends on the services sold and the contract actually concluded.
Claims under this regime are subject to a two-year limitation period, subject to the specific personal injury limitation period provided by Article 2226 of the French Civil Code.
Which insurance policies may be relevant?
Liability insurance for the operator’s business
Depending on the policy terms, this may cover the hotel or restaurant’s liability.
The property owner’s or property manager’s insurance
This may be relevant where the defect concerns the structure, a common area or equipment under that party’s custody and control.
A service provider’s insurance
A cleaning, maintenance, plumbing installation, lighting or events company may have its own liability cover.
The trip or event organiser’s insurance
This may be relevant where the fall occurs during a package holiday, seminar, wedding, organised stay or private event.
Personal accident cover (garantie accidents de la vie)
This may sometimes apply, depending on the policy’s definition of an accident, severity threshold, exclusions, limit of cover and time limits.
Legal expenses insurance
This may arrange or cover certain costs within the policy limits.
Reporting a claim does not amount to an admission of liability or confirmation of cover. It is useful to obtain requests for documents, offers and refusals in writing.
Which medical and financial documents should you keep?
Medical documents
- initial medical certificate (guide in French);
- emergency service and emergency department reports;
- hospital records, imaging and specialist reports;
- prescriptions and rehabilitation records;
- sick notes and follow-up certificates;
- records of psychological support, where provided;
- a certificate recording stabilisation of the condition (consolidation) or deterioration;
- the medical expert’s report.
Employment and financial documents
- payslips and employer statements;
- evidence of absence from work and lost earnings;
- travel and treatment expenses;
- additional overnight stays or an early return;
- assistance from another person;
- damaged equipment and personal belongings.
Documents relating to the stay
- the booking, invoice or restaurant bill;
- tickets, receipts and proof of payment;
- the accommodation contract or voucher;
- the incident report;
- any travel contract;
- correspondence with the establishment and insurers.
For missing medical documents, see the guide to obtaining your medical records after an accident or treatment (in French).
When might a medical expert assessment be needed?
An assessment may be considered where the injuries are significant, treatment continues, pain persists, time off work is prolonged, returning to work is difficult, assistance is needed or lasting effects are anticipated.
It may examine the initial injuries, their link to the fall, treatment, pain, temporary loss of independence, stabilisation of the condition (consolidation), lasting effects, assistance from another person, employment consequences and future expenses.
- Preparing for a medical expert assessment (in French);
- Understanding the role of a medical adviser assisting the injured person (in French);
- When to consult a lawyer before the assessment (in French).
Which consequences may be compensated?
Heads of loss are considered only where a third party’s liability or contractual insurance cover has been established. Each consequence must then be substantiated and linked to the fall.
Financial losses
- out-of-pocket healthcare expenses;
- travel expenses;
- lost earnings;
- assistance from another person;
- additional accommodation or return travel expenses;
- future expenses;
- wider effects on employment and career (incidence professionnelle).
Non-financial harm
- temporary functional impairment (déficit fonctionnel temporaire);
- pain and suffering (souffrances endurées);
- temporary or permanent harm to appearance (préjudice esthétique);
- permanent functional impairment (déficit fonctionnel permanent);
- loss of enjoyment of leisure activities (préjudice d’agrément);
- psychological consequences.
Family members’ own losses
- assistance provided;
- expenses incurred;
- lost earnings;
- the personal impact on them.
The guide to compensable losses after an accident (in French) explains these categories in more detail. Family members can also consult the page on their rights and their own losses (in French).
What if the establishment or its insurer refuses compensation?
Ask for a written response and identify precisely what is being disputed.
- whether the fall occurred;
- the cause of the accident;
- the abnormal condition of the floor, step or equipment;
- status as a customer or third party;
- the identity of the operator, owner or service provider;
- whether there was a breach;
- any fault alleged against the injured person;
- the link between the fall and the injuries;
- insurance cover;
- the time limit for reporting the accident;
- the amount claimed or the evidence supporting the losses.
The reasons given should then be compared with the photographs, witness accounts, invoices, bookings, reports, footage, cleaning or maintenance records, medical documents, contracts and medical expert’s report.
A general objection is less useful than an evidence-based response to the precise reason for refusal.
Which mistakes can weaken the claim?
- leaving the establishment without reporting the fall;
- failing to identify the precise location;
- waiting before photographing a floor that will be cleaned;
- failing to identify witnesses;
- not keeping the booking, restaurant bill or invoice;
- requesting footage too late;
- not seeking medical attention despite developing pain;
- sending original documents without keeping copies;
- naming a liable party without identifying their role;
- not checking the travel contract or personal insurance cover;
- accepting a final offer too quickly;
- publishing photographs of injuries or identifying third parties.
Which time limits should you watch?
Personal injury
A liability claim arising from an event that caused personal injury is, in principle, subject to a ten-year limitation period running from the stabilisation (consolidation) of the initial injury or its aggravation.
Package holidays
Claims under the French Tourism Code regime are subject to a two-year period, subject to the specific time limit applicable to personal injury.
Insurance
Policies may impose shorter deadlines for reporting the accident, submitting a certificate, seeking cover, challenging a refusal or attending a medical expert assessment.
Physical evidence
Even where the legal time limit seems long, the floor may be cleaned, the mat repositioned, furniture moved, bathroom fittings repaired and footage deleted. A prompt written request therefore remains essential.
Frequently asked questions
Is a hotel or restaurant liable for every fall?
No. A breach, defect or the causal role of a specific element must be established, along with the link to the injuries.
Does a hotel operator have a duty to guarantee a particular result?
No. The Cour de cassation describes its contractual safety obligation as an obligation de moyens: a duty to take appropriate care, rather than to guarantee a result. The circumstances and alleged defects must be proved.
Is a wet bathroom enough to establish liability?
Not automatically. The floor covering, layout, fittings, warnings, maintenance and precise cause of the fall must be examined.
Can a faulty washbasin or bathroom fitting give rise to liability?
Yes, where inadequate securing or maintenance caused or aggravated the injuries.
Is the absence of a handrail enough?
It may be an important factor, but the rules actually applicable to the building must be checked and the link to the fall established.
Is an invoice or booking enough to prove liability?
No. It mainly establishes presence and sometimes the contractual relationship, not the cause of the accident.
Does an incident report amount to an admission of liability?
Not necessarily. It mainly proves that the accident was reported. Its contents must be examined alongside the other evidence.
Can you request CCTV footage?
Yes. A precise request should be made promptly. Disclosure may, however, require other people shown in the footage to be protected.
Could a travel agency be involved?
Yes, where the hotel formed part of a package holiday or a service governed by the French Tourism Code. The precise role of the platform, organiser or retailer must be checked.
Are accessibility rules enough to prove liability?
No. They may help establish an abnormal condition or breach, but the harm and causal link must still be established.
Can pain that appears after leaving be reported?
Yes. Some pain develops gradually. It is useful to seek medical attention, have the findings dated and report the changes without altering the original account of the circumstances.
Useful official resources (in French)
- Légifrance – French Civil Code, Article 1231-1;
- Légifrance – French Civil Code, Articles 1240 to 1242;
- Légifrance – French Civil Code, Article 1353;
- Légifrance – French Civil Code, Article 2226;
- Légifrance – French Consumer Code, Article L. 421-3;
- Légifrance – French Construction and Housing Code, Article R. 164-1;
- Légifrance – Public accessibility register, Article R. 164-6;
- Légifrance – Order of 8 December 2014 on existing establishments open to the public;
- Légifrance – Order of 20 April 2017 on new establishments open to the public;
- Légifrance – French Tourism Code, Article L. 211-16;
- Légifrance – French Tourism Code, Article L. 211-17;
- Cour de cassation – Fall on a hotel staircase, 8 February 2005;
- Cour de cassation – Faulty restaurant washbasin, 26 November 1991;
- CNIL – CCTV in shops and the right of access.
Hotels, restaurants and establishments open to the public
Have you been injured in a fall in a hotel or restaurant?
The firm can review the circumstances, booking or invoice, photographs, incident report, cleaning or maintenance records, initial medical documents, accommodation contract and potentially relevant insurance cover.
For an initial discussion, there is no need to send your entire medical file or images that unnecessarily identify customers or staff without being asked. An appropriate way to send documents can be agreed after the first discussion.