Practical guide
Fall in a shop or supermarket in France: compensation and evidence
A fall in a shop can cause a fracture, head injury, back, shoulder or knee injury, time off work and sometimes lasting impairments. The victim's mere presence in the shop and the…
Free initial consultation — no obligation.
A fall in a shop can cause a fracture, head injury, back, shoulder or knee injury, time off work and sometimes lasting impairments.
The victim’s mere presence in the shop and the fact that a fall occurred are not, however, enough to establish the operator’s liability automatically.
Identify what caused the accident: liquid on the floor, rubbish, a raised mat, a poorly placed obstacle, a hard-to-see step, inadequate lighting or another specific factor.
This guide explains the initial steps, evidence to gather promptly, the parties who may be responsible, medical records to keep and points to check if the insurer refuses the claim.
Which situations does this guide mainly cover?
This page mainly concerns falls in the walkways of a shop, supermarket or large retail store.
- slipping on a spilled liquid or product;
- an abnormally slippery floor;
- a folded, raised or poorly secured entrance mat;
- a box, pallet, trolley or display in an aisle;
- a step or level change that is difficult to see;
- inadequate signs or lighting;
- an obstacle in an area normally used by customers.
Where the accident involves mechanical equipment, a car park or a falling object, the liability issues and evidence may differ.
- Lift or escalator accidents (in French);
- Accidents in car parks (in French);
- An object falling on a person (in French).
What should you do immediately after the fall?
The victim’s health is the priority. For significant pain, a head impact, feeling unwell or difficulty getting up, seek help and contact the emergency services where necessary.
Where possible, take several steps before the scene is cleaned or altered.
- notify staff immediately;
- ask for a manager to attend;
- have the incident recorded in writing;
- photograph the location and the item that caused the fall;
- collect witnesses’ contact details;
- keep the receipt or other proof of your presence;
- promptly request preservation of CCTV footage;
- see a healthcare professional and keep medical documents;
- notify any personal insurers that may provide cover.
If the shop provides no copy of its internal report, send a factual email the same day recording the date, time, exact location, observed cause, witnesses and any emergency service attendance.
Is the shop automatically liable?
No. The fact that a fall occurred in a shop does not, on its own, establish the business’s liability.
The victim must be able to establish the accident circumstances, the role of the element causing the fall, the injuries and the link between the fall and those injuries.
Compensation is therefore harder to obtain for a fall whose cause remains entirely unknown than for a fall caused by a specifically identified liquid, item of rubbish or obstacle.
Article 1353 of the Civil Code states that a person seeking performance of an obligation must prove it. Photographs, witness accounts, statements and medical documents are therefore central to such claims.
What role did the floor, obstacle or object play in the fall?
Liability may be pursued where an object under a person’s custody caused the harm. In a shop, this may be a slippery floor, mat, sign, pallet, box, display or another physical element.
Where the object was moving
The object’s role may be more directly identifiable where it struck the victim, moved or fell. Identify who had custody of it and preserve evidence that allows the events to be reconstructed.
Where the object was stationary
For an inert object – a floor, mat, step, sign or stationary obstacle – the victim must generally establish an abnormal position, poor condition or a defect that caused the fall.
The presence of a visible object in a normal position is therefore not always sufficient to establish the liability of the person with custody.
What may indicate an abnormal situation?
- a puddle or liquid making the floor slippery;
- fruit, vegetable or food waste on the floor;
- a folded, raised or poorly secured mat;
- a box, pallet or trolley in a walkway;
- a display that is difficult to see or placed in the passage;
- a step or level change that cannot readily be seen;
- a recently cleaned area without appropriate signs;
- inadequate lighting concealing the obstacle or change in level.
The analysis must remain factual. A wet floor, for example, is not necessarily abnormally slippery. Its condition, visibility, any lack of signs and precise role in the fall must be explained.
Is the shop’s safety obligation enough?
No. The shop does not owe every customer an obligation to guarantee a result that would make every fall automatically compensable.
The accident circumstances, the role of an object or a specific breach must still be established.
Can fault or negligence by the shop be alleged?
Depending on the circumstances, fault, carelessness or negligence may also be relevant.
- known liquid left uncleared;
- no warning signs after floor cleaning;
- an obstacle left in an aisle for a prolonged period;
- unstable or incorrectly installed equipment;
- a known maintenance defect;
- faulty lighting left unrepaired.
The alleged breach must be precisely demonstrated and linked to the accident. A general assertion that the shop should have prevented every fall is insufficient.
What evidence should you keep after the fall?
Photograph the scene before it changes
- an overview of the aisle, entrance or area concerned;
- a close-up of the liquid, mat or obstacle;
- the position of the element in relation to the walkway;
- the presence or absence of a warning sign;
- the area’s lighting;
- the condition of the floor, mat, step or equipment.
Photographs should show both the wider surroundings and the detail of the defect. A close-up with no indication of location may be difficult to interpret.
Identify witnesses
Ask for the names, phone numbers and email addresses of people who saw the fall or observed the scene immediately afterwards.
A witness may describe a puddle, the position of a box, missing signs, staff’s initial statements or emergency service attendance.
Have an incident statement recorded
The victim may ask a shop manager to record the accident in writing and provide a copy. Failing that, they can confirm the facts themselves by email the same day.
The statement should include the date, time, precise location, observed cause, witnesses and any emergency service attendance.
An internal statement usefully establishes that the incident was reported, but does not necessarily amount to an admission of liability by the shop.
Keep proof of your presence
A till receipt, bank payment, loyalty card, collection slip or customer service exchange can help establish that the victim was in the shop.
They do not, however, prove the cause of the fall on their own.
Protect personal data
Do not publish photographs of others, CCTV footage, medical certificates or documents identifying people in public comments.
Keep the originals and send sensitive documents through an appropriate channel.
How can you request CCTV footage?
Send a written request promptly to the shop or site manager. Footage is retained only for a limited time and may be erased before liability is discussed.
The request should state as precisely as possible:
- the accident date;
- the time or a short time window;
- the exact location;
- a description enabling the victim to be identified;
- a request to preserve footage of the incident;
- a request for access to footage showing the victim, where possible.
Disclosure may require other people to be obscured. Even if footage is not immediately provided, preserving it may be decisive.
Who may be liable for the fall?
Who should receive the claim depends on the exact location and the element that caused the accident.
- the shop operator;
- the shopping arcade manager;
- the owner or manager of a communal area;
- a cleaning or maintenance company;
- the person with custody of an object or equipment;
- another customer where their behaviour or an object under their custody directly caused the accident.
Do not automatically direct every claim to the shop without checking who controlled the location, object or activity that caused the fall.
In a shopping arcade, for example, the walkway may be the centre manager’s responsibility while the shop interior is controlled by the shop operator. Cleaning in progress may also involve an outside contractor.
Which insurance policies may apply?
- the operator’s or manager’s liability insurance;
- a cleaning company’s or contractor’s insurance;
- another customer’s liability insurance;
- the victim’s personal accident insurance (in French);
- legal expenses cover;
- school or extracurricular insurance for a minor, depending on the policy.
Personal cover has its own limits, thresholds, exclusions and notification deadlines. It must not be confused with the shop’s civil liability.
Requesting the shop’s insurer details is useful, but the insurer is not itself responsible for causing the accident. Its involvement depends on its policyholder’s liability and policy terms.
Which medical documents should be kept?
- a medical certificate issued after the fall (in French);
- the emergency department report;
- diagnostic imaging;
- hospital or procedure reports;
- prescriptions;
- sick leave certificates;
- extension or follow-up certificates;
- rehabilitation prescriptions;
- invoices and transport evidence;
- the medico-legal assessment report where an assessment is arranged.
A consultation close to the fall date helps establish the medical chronology. A later consultation does not necessarily prevent a claim, but the link between the accident and injuries may be more disputed.
Where pain changes, documents should be arranged chronologically to connect the initial injuries, treatment and persistent consequences.
When might a medico-legal assessment be needed?
An assessment may be arranged where injuries are serious, time off work continues, lasting impairments are anticipated or the insurer needs to evaluate the consequences.
It may examine:
- the initial injuries;
- treatment and hospital stays;
- physical and psychological pain;
- temporary loss of independence;
- medical stabilisation;
- lasting impairments;
- the need for personal assistance;
- occupational consequences;
- future treatment and expenses.
Preparing for a medico-legal assessment after an accident (in French)
Which heads of loss may be examined?
Where a third party’s liability or contractual cover is established, compensation must be assessed against the fall’s actual consequences.
- healthcare and out-of-pocket expenses (in French);
- transport and other treatment-related expenses;
- lost earnings (in French);
- temporary or permanent personal assistance (in French);
- temporary functional impairment (in French);
- pain and suffering (in French);
- temporary or permanent disfigurement (in French);
- permanent functional impairment (in French);
- loss of enjoyment of specific leisure activities (in French);
- wider effects on working life (in French);
- property damage, such as damaged glasses, clothing or a phone.
Each head of loss must be supported. Looking only at the overall offer is not enough: check the medical findings, evidence and calculation basis for each item.
What if the shop or its insurer refuses compensation?
First request a written response setting out the precise reasons for refusal.
- is the fall itself disputed?
- is its cause considered unproven?
- is the abnormal condition of the floor or obstacle disputed?
- does the shop argue that another party is responsible?
- is fault or inattention alleged against the victim?
- is the link between the fall and injuries disputed?
- are some heads of loss considered inadequately supported?
Compare the response with photographs, witness accounts, medical documents, statements, any video footage and the rest of the file.
A refusal does not necessarily mean that no action is possible. The quality of the available evidence and potential legal basis must nevertheless be assessed realistically.
Which mistakes can weaken the case?
- leaving the shop without reporting the fall;
- failing to obtain witnesses’ contact details;
- taking photographs after cleaning or movement of the obstacle;
- relying only on the receipt without documenting the cause;
- delaying a request to preserve footage;
- failing to keep correspondence with the shop or insurer;
- accepting a proposal before knowing how the medical condition develops;
- sending originals without keeping copies.
What time limit applies?
Under ordinary civil law, a liability action arising from an event causing personal injury is generally subject to a ten-year limitation period from medical stabilisation of the initial or aggravated injury.
This should not lead to delay. Footage may be erased, the floor cleaned, the obstacle moved and witnesses become difficult to trace.
Notifications under personal insurance policies may also have shorter contractual deadlines. Check the relevant policies promptly.
Frequently asked questions
Is the shop liable merely because the fall occurred there?
No. Establish the fall’s circumstances and the role of a specific element, or demonstrate a breach directly linked to the accident.
Does having no witness prevent any claim?
No, but it may make proof harder. Photographs, an immediate report, footage, the receipt and medical chronology may then become more important.
Is a receipt enough?
No. It may establish the victim’s presence in the shop, but does not prove the cause of the fall by itself.
Does an accident statement signed by the shop amount to an admission of liability?
Not necessarily. It mainly proves that the incident was reported. Its exact contents must be examined.
Is a wet floor enough to establish liability?
Not automatically. It must be shown that its condition was abnormal and actually caused the fall.
Can camera footage be requested?
Yes. A person may request access to footage showing them. Send the request promptly with the accident’s precise date, time and location.
Can inattention be alleged against the victim?
Yes. Its effect depends on the circumstances and legal basis. It should not, however, be presumed solely because the victim did not see the obstacle.
Can a fall be reported if there was no immediate injury?
Yes. Some pain or injuries develop gradually. Report the incident and seek medical advice if a symptom appears.
Can personal accident insurance apply?
It may sometimes apply under the policy terms, including severity thresholds, exclusions and limits. It does not automatically replace the shop’s liability.
Useful resources
For further information, consult the official legislation and resources on civil liability, evidence, service safety and CCTV footage.
- Civil Code – Article 1240 (in French)
- Civil Code – Article 1241 (in French)
- Civil Code – Article 1242 (in French)
- Civil Code – Article 1353 (in French)
- Civil Code – Article 2226 (in French)
- Consumer Code – Article L. 421-3 (in French)
- Court of Cassation – 9 September 2020, a fall in a shop and the safety obligation (in French)
- Court of Cassation – 24 November 2021, an inert object and abnormal position (in French)
- CNIL – CCTV in shops (in French)
- See the other practical personal injury guides (in French)
Preserving accident evidence
Were you injured in a fall in a shop or supermarket?
The firm can review the circumstances, photographs, witness accounts, medical documents, the shop’s response and potentially relevant insurance.